Order in the matter of Eltrol Ltd

WTM/PS/27/IVD/ID-4/JULY/2010 BEFORE THE SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE BOARD OF INDIA CORAM: PRASHANT SARAN, WHOLE TIME MEMBER IN THE MATTER OF ELTROL LTD. ORDER Under Sections 11B, 11D and 11(4) of Securities and Exchange Board of India Act, 1992 1. Securities and Exchange Board of India (hereinafter referred to as ‘SEBI’), upon noticing sudden variation in price and volume in the shares of Eltrol Ltd. (hereinafter referred to as ‘Eltrol’) presently known as Shree Mahaganga Sugar Mills Ltd. conducted a preliminary examination of the dealings in the scrip. The preliminary examination revealed that the price of the scrip of Eltrol (having face value Re.1) at Bombay Stock Exchange Ltd. (hereinafter referred to as ‘BSE’) opened on January 05, 2005 at Rs.0.80 and the same increased to Rs.6.90 on August 14, 2005. Substantial variations in the daily traded volumes of scrip of Eltrol were also observed with the lowest volume on July 1, 2005, when only one share was traded and the highest being on August 26, 2005, when 1,36,70,180 shares were traded.

2. Pursuant to the preliminary investigation, SEBI vide an ad interim ex-parte Order dated October 05, 2005 issued under Sections 11B, 11D and 11(4) of Securities and Exchange Board of India Act, 1992 (hereinafter referred to as ‘SEBI Act’), pending inquiry, directed Eltrol not to issue any equity shares or any other instrument convertible into equity shares or alter its capital structure in any manner till further directions in this regard. Eltrol was also directed to cease dealings in the securities market in any manner, directly or indirectly, till further direction. Further, the directors of Eltrol namely, Mr. Sanjay Tripathi, Mr. Deepak Rathod, Mr. Niraj Sanghvi and Mr. Chittarmal Sharma were also directed not to buy, sell, pledge or deal in securities of Eltrol, directly or indirectly, till further directions in this regard. Vide this order, suitable directions were also issued against 7 brokers of National Stock Exchange (hereinafter referred to as ‘NSE’), 11 brokers of BSE, 10 trading clients at BSE and 25 clients apparently connected with/ related to each other.

3. The said interim order also provided the entities/ persons to whom directions were issued to file their objections, if any, to the order within 15 days from the date of order and, if they so desire, avail themselves of an opportunity of personal hearing. However, only Eltrol and a broker namely Harikishan Hiralal filed their objections and requested for a personal hearing in the matter. Thereafter, an opportunity of inspection was afforded to Eltrol, which was conducted on November 23, 2005. Pursuant to this, an opportunity of personal hearing was granted to Eltrol on January 25, 2006. Thereafter the investigation in the matter was completed and suitable actions against the entities covered in the interim order and others, had been initiated. I note that some of the proceedings have been culminated by passing of the final orders. The approved actions in respect of the persons covered under the ad interim ex-parte Order and the status thereof are tabulated below:

S.No Name of entity Action approved Action taken 1. Eltrol Ltd. 11B Debarred for 5 years. 2. Sanjay G. Tripathi 11B Debarred for 6 3. Niraj Sanghvi 11B months. 4. Deepak Rathod 11B 5. Chittarmal Sharma Warned 6. P.J. Chaudhary Adjudication Penalty Rs.1 lac 7. Sanchay Fincom Ltd. Adjudication Penalty Rs. 50,000 8. M/s. Harikishan Hiralal Adjudication No Penalty 9. Bakliwal Financial Services (India) P. Ltd. Adjudication No Penalty 10. JMP Sec. Pvt. Ltd. No Action 11. Amit Sahita Finance Pvt. No Action 12. M.R. Share Broker Ltd. No Action 13. S.M. Nissar No Action 14. NCJ Share & Stock Brokers No Action 15. Adolf Pinto No Action 16. Indus Portfolio P. Ltd. No Action 17. S.S. Corporate Securities Ltd. No Action 18. Indus Portfolio (P.) Ltd. No Action 19. Indiabulls Securities Ltd. No Action 20. Insight Share Brokers Pvt. Ltd.* No Action 21. Bakliwal Financial Services (India) P. Ltd. No Action 22. SSJ Holdings Private Limited No Action 23. Insight Share Brokers Pvt. Ltd.* No Action 24. Pravinkumar Jain (Maars Software) Adjudication Penalty Rs.1 lakh 25. Priyam Securities (Premsukh Kandelwal) Adjudication Penalty Rs.50,000 26. Navin Patel Adjudication Penalty Rs.7 lacs 27. Jayeshkumar Shah Adjudication Penalty Rs.7 lacs 28. Dalsukhbhai Patel Adjudication Penalty Rs.7 lacs 29. Vinod Patel Adjudication Penalty Rs.7 lacs 30. Ramniklal Patel Adjudication Penalty Rs.5 lacs 31. Vikas Naknavar Adjudication Penalty Rs.5 lacs 32. Vikas Bengani Adjudication Penalty Rs.10,000 (SAT – No Penalty) 33. Anil Solanki Adjudication Pending 34. Ramdas Kshirsagar, Director of IFSL Ltd. Adjudication Pending

35. Charu Niraj Sanghvi Adjudication Pending 36. Vikram Singh Rajput Adjudication Pending 37. Shivaram Motilal Meena Adjudication Pending 38. Kusum Deepak Rathod Adjudication Pending 39. T.H. Vakil Shares And Securities P. Ltd. Adjudication Pending 40. Mangalaben A Doshi Adjudication Pending 41. Ashwin D. Doshi Adjudication Pending 42. Viral C. Shah Adjudication Pending 43. Jignesh P. Lakhlani Adjudication Pending 44. Navin Trikamdas Thakkar Adjudication Pending 45. Tarun V. Shah Adjudication Pending 46. Shilpa P. Sakpal Adjudication Pending 47. Amit Easy Finance Ltd. Adjudication Pending 48. Harsiddhi Man-Power Services Pvt. Ltd. Adjudication Pending 49. Shreerath Marketing Private Ltd. Adjudication Pending 50. Lila Laboratories (India ) Ltd. Adjudication Pending 51. Hitendra Chaturbhai Makwana Adjudication Pending 52. Karni Ajaysingh Jagdishsingh Rathore Adjudication Pending 53. Mahesh Vora (JMP Securities Pvt. Ltd.) No Action 54. Amit Sahita Finance Pvt. Ltd. No Action 55. Bhagwandas Jaju No Action 56. Shailesh Nissar No Action 57. Naresh Jain No Action 58. Anil Kantilal Shah No Action * The name of Insight Share Brokers Pvt. Ltd. has been inadvertently mentioned twice in the ad interim ex-parte Order

4. Therefore, taking into consideration the facts and circumstances of the case and various actions initiated against the aforesaid persons, I am of the view that the interim directions need not be continued in respect of them.

5. Accordingly, I, in exercise of the powers conferred upon me under Section 19 of the SEBI Act read with Sections 11, 11B and 11(4) thereof, do hereby revoke the interim directions issued vide ad interim ex-parte order dated October 05, 2005, against all the entities mentioned in the table at paragraph 3 above, with immediate effect.

6. Wherever, the adjudication proceedings are pending, the same shall be disposed of by the concerned Adjudicating Officers, in accordance with the SEBI Act and SEBI (Procedure for Holding Enquiry and Imposing Penalty by Adjudicating Officer) Rules, 1995, and pass an appropriate order on merits, at the earliest, uninfluenced by this Order.

DATE : 28/JULY/2010 PRASHANT SARAN PLACE: MUMBAI WHOLE TIME MEMBER SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE BOARD OF INDIA